Friday, 11 April 2025

Drawing the dead and the dying

 


When my mother was dying I used to go down to my home town every weekend to see her and sit with her. I drew her several times and when she finally passed away I made images from the drawings as a way to come to terms with how I felt about her death. She was always surrounded by her 'tranculments', which had by then mainly been placed in glass fronted cabinets, but several, such as the swan vases, still adorned any spare surface, such as the top of the TV. I could find myself dizzy with the carpet pattern, often just looking for somewhere to rest my eyes, and when they rested on her, she seemed the most insubstantial thing in the room. I have a drawing of her where she literally dissolves into her chair and others where she becomes manic in her distress or lost in her bed. One drawing I made of her in bed, shows her dissolving into the pillow, whilst the bedspread becomes a repository of stories from her life. I drew all sorts of events that she had told me about, including the time when her sister Mary had trapped her foot in a rail line junction point, and how they were terrified a train would come. I tried to remember when she was happy and times when we were together, but there were many sad times too. Eventually the bedspread was covered with memories. 
When I first met Paulo Luís Almeida, he was giving a talk about his own response to a parent dying. He drew his father during the last years of his life as he succumbed to Parkinson’s disease, and Paulo spoke about the erosion of language and the disappearance of his father's world. Paulo went on to say that drawing 'incited a memorialising function of the trace'. Empathy was in his case the key issue, whilst for myself it was simply loss.

Paulo Luís Almeida: Untitled 2011

Maggie Hambling drew both her mother and her father as they were dying. 


Maggie Hambling

Hambling's drawings use a searching line that I feel attempts to give back life to the dead. Her own energy of looking is locked into these images forever, and when she has herself passed on, she will still exist in the frozen moments of her looking. 

Occasionally Foundation students used to ask me if they could get to draw dead people and the only person I knew at the time that had a way in to do this was Brian Holmes. I remember that I drew his portrait at one time, as he used to live just around the corner from where I lived in Kirkstall, however where that drawing is now I haven't a clue and he is now long dead, a reminder that every portrait ever made is in fact a memento mori. Brian was at one point commissioned by the School of Medicine of the University of Leeds to paint a mural detailing the history of Leeds Medical School and that meant he had access to their facilities, including the dissection area.

Brian Holmes: Detail of Leeds Medical School 

Brian Holmes: Foot: Etching

Brian used to go in to the anatomy area and draw bodies and could occasionally, if asked, get a student to go in with him. One of the students that asked me if he could get access was Damien Hirst, who always asserts that he was influenced by his visits to the anatomy department of Leeds Medical School and that he made anatomical drawings there. None of these drawings seem to have surfaced, but the photograph 'With dead head' has become an iconic part of his oeuvre. I'm not even sure if Brian was able to get Damien in and Damien may well have found a different way to get access, the point being that it was his association with the ever present idea of death, that to some extent signalled him out at the time as an artist of significance. 

Charles Emile Callande de Champmartin
Théodore Géricault was well known for painting and drawing the dead. In fact the image above was thought to be by him until a cleaning revealed the signature of his friend and follower Charles Emile Champmartin. Ironically the painting actually depicts Géricault himself on his deathbed. At the time, he was such an iconic trope of the tragic Romantic artist, that copies of his death mask were often found in young artists’ studios. 

Géricault: Deathmask

We all have to confront death at some time, it is a normal part of life and most cultures have embedded within them ways to come to terms with this fact. Except I feel our own, where we rarely see dead people.  Perhaps we all need to remember that we are dying, and in doing so, we might value life that much more. 

Head of the dead Christ: Durer

During the many years that Christianity formed the dominant religion of the Western World, images of the dead or dying Christ were available for everyone to see. People were constantly therefore being reminded of how death was a central fact of life. In traditional Buddhist teachings, contemplating death is an integral part of meditation. Buddha states that death is “the greatest of all teachers”; it teaches us to be humble, destroys vanity and pride and crumbles all the barriers of caste, creed and race that divide humans, for all living beings are destined to die. 

Kusôzu

Perhaps we need a return to the old Japanese Buddhist tradition of Kusôzu, whereby images were made of the sequential decay of a cadaver; not pretty but a clear message. The Roman Egyptian idea of encaustic "Fayum portraits," which were placed over the heads of mummies in coffins, is an interesting take on mortality and portraiture. These were not only realistic depictions of the deceased, the images were kept on the walls of the houses of the living and then when someone died they would be transferred to the coffin. So you would have been very aware that when the artist came to do your portrait, that its final resting place would be the same as yours. Being made in encaustic, which is an amazingly long lasting paint material, your image would like Dorian Gray stay youthful, whilst you would decay like Gray's portrait. Wilde's neat role reversal idea, in many ways highlighting our mortal condition.

A Fayum portrait

If I had to show one image that transcended the genre it would be the one below by Käthe
 Kollwitz. Kollwitz drew the workers that she met, particularly women who struggled to keep themselves alive under the most harsh conditions. In this image the woman you feel can see her own death in a not very far off future, a black ghost already sitting at her shoulder. But at the same time Kollwitz has found a deep humanity in this woman, she is a solid yet wonderfully delicate presence, on the one hand to be blown away by the trials of a hard life and yet on the other she is preserved, rock like, in all her dignity within Kollwitz's drawing. She is always in that moment that she appeared to Kollwitz, time past, present and future unravel and we are forever in the now of her being. 
 
Käthe Kollwitz

See also:

Dat

Artis

Saturday, 5 April 2025

Jonathan Richardson's self-portraits

Self portrait: Foot pain and its emotional effects

I have been making drawings and printed images of people, whereby I listen to them talk to me about their internal perceptions, (interoceptions) of pain, emotion and other inner body feelings. Essentially what I am making are a series of portraits, but images that attempt to reflect the interior world of people, rather than their external appearance. My fellow researcher at the Leeds Arts University, Dawn Woolley is focused on the photographic selfie, so it feels as if we have both interior and exterior awareness covered.
When thinking about a history that might lie behind my approach, I began by looking at expressionist portraiture, but as I dug around the subject, the more I came across the self portraits of Jonathan Richardson. 

Jonathan Richardson, Self-portrait, c. 1735

Richardson made hundreds of drawn self portraits over a period of several years. This type of serial facial analysis looked at from a present perspective, feels very modern. For instance in relation to expressionist portraits, in three of his more prolific years, Vincent van Gogh, drew and painted himself over 40 times. and as photography has become the main form of facial representation, serial portraits, such as Jo Spence's 'Brave' series, have become central to documentary practices.

Jonathan Richardson, Self-portrait, c. 1738

Richardson even went back to earlier work and made drawn copies of his self-portraits from paintings made many years earlier. Most of his self portraits are however drawn from life, using a variety of materials, including pen and ink, graphite on vellum but mainly black and white chalks on blue paper.

Jonathan Richardson Self-portrait as a poet, c. 1732

Jonathan Richardson, Self-portrait, c. 1728

During his early career as a portrait painter he defined his trade in this way, "a portrait is a sort of General History of the Life of the Person it represents, not only to Him who is acquainted with it, but to Many Others, who upon Occasion of seeing it are frequently told, of what is most Material concerning Them, or their General Character at least." However his later self-portraits, which are nearly all dated, are not a ‘General History’ of his life, they are far too particular. They represent the complexity of an inner emotional life, rather than the status or occupation of the sitter.

Jonathan Richardson Self-portrait at the age of thirty, 1735

Jonathan Richardson Self-portrait, 1736

I find his portraits intriguing, especially how with slight differences in the openness of an eye, or width of a face, as well as by changing materials, he can give quite different impressions as to what he is thinking about as he gazes at himself. His images can feel very confident, or fragile, slightly sly or arrogant, quizzical or poetic but they don't feel forced or exaggerated as in Charles le Brun's  work or 
Messerschmitt portraits.

Charles le Brun: The expressions

Messerschmitt: Character Head

I first came across Jonathan Richardson in the chapter 'Searching for the self' in Susan Owens' excellent book, 'The Story of Drawing'. It is a book well worth a read if you are interested in how drawing supports the various ways that artists think about what it is that they do. We might value painting far more, but it is often an artist's drawings that reveal their thoughts and the roots of their sensibilities; the paintings or sculptures done afterwards often covering up the thinking surrounding an idea's gestation.

Richardson's portraits reminded me that you don't need to go 'over the top' when looking for expression and that it is often in small details that a telling communication is made. He also made his self portraits as he neared the end of his career, something I am also doing. It being a time to continue working if you still have the capability but the pressure to earn money or get out there to make your name is less and you can therefore reflect more on what you have done and how perhaps you can do it in a more interesting or personal way. 

See also: